A double garage is more than just a place to park cars—it can be a workshop, storage space, or even an extension of your home. But when it comes to choosing between a traditional and a shed-style double garage, the decision isn’t always straightforward.
Both options come with advantages and drawbacks, and the right choice depends on your budget, property layout, aesthetic preferences, and long-term plans. In this article, we’ll compare traditional and shed-style double garages to help you determine which one is the best fit for your home.
What is a Traditional Double Garage?
A traditional double garage is typically a permanent structure built using materials like brick, concrete, or timber framing with a tiled or metal roof. These garages are often designed to match the home’s existing architecture, creating a seamless and cohesive look.
Pros of a Traditional Double Garage
✔ Durability & Longevity – Traditional garages are built to last, often standing for decades with minimal maintenance. They can withstand extreme weather conditions better than many prefab or shed-style alternatives.
✔ Aesthetic Appeal – Because they are custom-built, traditional garages can be designed to blend with your home, adding to its curb appeal and overall property value.
✔ Insulation & Climate Control – Traditional garages are easier to insulate, making them more comfortable for year-round use—perfect if you plan to use the space as a home gym, office, or workshop.
✔ Higher Property Value – A well-built double garage can increase the resale value of your home, as many buyers prefer solid, long-lasting structures over temporary solutions.
✔ Security & Safety – With stronger doors, windows, and walls, traditional garages offer better security for your vehicles and belongings.
Cons of a Traditional Double Garage
✖ Higher Cost – Traditional garages are significantly more expensive than shed-style alternatives due to materials, labour, and potential permit requirements.
✖ Longer Construction Time – Building a traditional garage can take weeks or even months, depending on the complexity of the design and weather conditions.
✖ Requires More Space – Because they often have thicker walls and require a solid foundation, traditional garages need more space than a shed-style garage.
What is a Shed-Style Double Garage?
A shed-style double garage is a prefabricated or kit-based structure made from materials like steel, timber, or aluminium. These garages are often designed as cost-effective, quick-install solutions for homeowners who need extra storage or parking space.
Pros of a Shed-Style Double Garage
✔ Affordability – Shed-style garages are typically cheaper than traditional builds, making them a great option for those on a budget.
✔ Faster Installation – Many shed garages are available in pre-built kits that can be assembled within a few days, unlike traditional garages, which require lengthy construction.
✔ Flexible Design & Placement – These garages are often modular, allowing for easy expansion or relocation if needed.
✔ Minimal Site Preparation – Unlike traditional garages, which need extensive groundwork, shed-style garages can often be installed with a simple gravel or concrete slab base.
✔ Low Maintenance – Modern steel shed garages require less maintenance than timber-built structures, as they are resistant to termites, rot, and warping.
Cons of a Shed-Style Double Garage
✖ Less Durable – While high-quality shed-style garages can last for decades, they may not be as structurally strong as brick or concrete garages, especially in extreme weather conditions.
✖ Limited Aesthetic Appeal – Shed-style garages are often seen as more functional than stylish, and may not blend seamlessly with your home’s design.
✖ Less Insulation – Unless additional insulation is added, these garages can be hot in summer and cold in winter, making them less suitable for multi-purpose use.
✖ Potential Council Restrictions – Some councils have regulations regarding the size, height, and materials of shed-style garages, so it’s important to check local building codes before installation.
Which One is Right for You?
Go for a Traditional Double Garage if…
✔ You want a permanent, high-value addition to your home
✔ You prefer a garage that matches your house’s architecture
✔ You plan to use the space for more than just storage (e.g., workshop, office, gym)
✔ You want better insulation and security
Opt for a Shed-Style Double Garage if…
✔ You need a quick and affordable garage solution
✔ You prefer a low-maintenance option
✔ You want a flexible, modular garage that can be relocated or expanded
✔ You have limited space and don’t want extensive site preparation
Cost Comparison: Traditional vs. Shed-Style Double Garages
| Feature | Traditional Double Garage | Shed-Style Double Garage |
| Average Cost | $$$ – Higher | $ – More Affordable |
| Construction Time | 4–12 weeks | 2–5 days |
| Durability | Extremely durable | Moderately durable |
| Aesthetic Appeal | High – Matches home | Functional, but basic |
| Insulation | Good | Limited |
| Security | High | Moderate |
| Customisation | Fully customisable | Limited options |
| Maintenance | Moderate | Low |
Final Thoughts
Choosing between a traditional and a shed-style double garage depends on your priorities.
- If long-term investment, security, and aesthetics matter most, a traditional double garage is worth considering.
- If you’re looking for a quick, budget-friendly, and functional option, a shed-style double garage may be the ideal choice.
Before making a decision, consider your budget, property layout, and intended use for the garage. No matter which option you choose, a well-designed double garage can provide extra space, functionality, and value to your home.
Would you like help with finding specific shed garage designs or local regulations? Let me know!
